Tuesday, September 22, 2020
Home Global New York DA's office says Trump's arguments over subpoena have already been...

New York DA’s office says Trump’s arguments over subpoena have already been rejected by courts

(CNN)Manhattan District Attorney Cy Vance’s office told a federal court Thursday that President Donald Trump’s effort to block a subpoena for years of his financial records is based only on “repackaging” arguments previously rejected by the courts.

Vance’s office said in its filing with the 2nd US Circuit Court of Appeals that courts have previously rejected the claim the subpoena is overbroad and issued in bad faith. The office further argued that Trump has failed to “demonstrate any irreparable harm” if the subpoena to his longtime accounting firm, Mazars USA, remains enforceable and that the public interest weights against his effort to “interrupt presumptively valid state criminal process.”
“In short, although Appellant’s claim of ‘temporary absolute immunity’ has been rejected at every level of the federal courts, by continuing to litigate this action he has effectively obtained temporary absolute immunity by delaying the grand jury’s receipt of the evidence it seeks,” Vance’s office wrote. “As the district court observed, ‘[j]ustice requires an end to this controversy.'”
Earlier this week, Vance’s office said that it had agreed not to enforce the subpoena, which had been set to expire this week, until after a federal appeals court has ruled on Trump’s request for a stay pending appeal of his lawsuit. The court is due to hear oral arguments in the case on September 1.
In its filing Thursday, Vance’s office also noted that Trump’s argument to the appeals court “depends on the implausible premise that, at the time the Mazars Subpoena issued, the grand jury’s investigation was limited to payments Michael Cohen made in 2016.” Trump, however, “has been put on notice throughout this litigation that the grand jury’s investigation was not limited to Cohen’s 2016 payments,” Vance’s office wrote.

5 COMMENTS

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisment -

Most Popular

Trump: ‘I’m so angry at Republicans’

Those calls had largely gone unheeded by Republicans who control the Senate until they nabbed a foothold recently after the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs committee voted to authorize more than three dozen subpoenas and depositions to compel testimony from former FBI Director James Comey and others. Trump lashed out at Comey, a frequent…

Lagoa’s Role in Florida Will Be a Big Factor in Trump’s Supreme Court Pick

Judge Barbara Lagoa lacks some of the usual credentials of a Supreme Court justice, but her roots in the Cuban-American community could make her an attractive choice for President Trump.The U.S.-born daughter of Cuban exiles, Judge Barbara Lagoa embodies Miami’s longstanding version of the American dream.Credit...Wilfredo Lee/Associated PressSept. 21, 2020Updated 8:30 p.m. ETMIAMI — As…

Biden marks grim coronavirus milestone, says ‘Trump panicked’ on pandemic

As the national death toll from the coronavirus pandemic passes 200,000 people, Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden cautioned that Americans must avoid “becoming numb to the toll that is taken.”The former vice president, speaking Monday at an aluminum manufacturing foundry in the crucial battleground state of Wisconsin, once against blasted President Trump’s handling of the pandemic,…

L.A.-Area Bobcat Fire Flares Up, “Making A Hard Push” For Mt. Wilson

After days of backfires and dozer lines had held the Bobcat Fire away from the Mt. Wilson Observatory and communications infrastructure there, The U.S. Forest Service reports that the fire “is making a hard push” at Mt. Wilson, and “defensive strategic operations are beginning from Mt. Wilson to the west.” Every TV station in Los…