Thursday, October 22, 2020
Home Africa CDC Now Says COVID-19 Isn't Airborne Threat. Scientists Say That’s Wrong. -...

CDC Now Says COVID-19 Isn’t Airborne Threat. Scientists Say That’s Wrong. – HuffPost


Scientists are firing back at theCenters for Disease Control and Preventionafter the federal agency on Mondayreversed its identification of thecoronavirusas an airborne virus, a conclusion thatmany experts say scientific evidence has supported for months now.

The CDC’s brief recognition of the virus as being airborne on Friday was celebrated as long overdue by concurring scientists, who expressed relief that the agency was finally catching up. Three days later, however, the agency said that new language in its coronavirus guidance had been published in error.

“The CDC is broken. Seriously broken,” Matthew Fox, an epidemiology and global health professor at Boston University, tweeted in response.

Scientists and public health experts scoffed at the CDC’s flip-flop. Not only was it dangerous to release confusing information during a pandemic, they argued, but the science doesn’t support the stance the agency was apparently reverting to.

“There’s something odd going on at the CDC,”tweeted Joseph Allen of the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health.

A registered nurse makes her way to a patient's room inside the coronavirus unit at Houston's United Memorial Medical Center.



A registered nurse makes her way to a patient’s room inside the coronavirus unit at Houston’s United Memorial Medical Center. If the coronavirus is airborne, as many scientists say it is, health experts urge the use of masks and air filtration systems to help prevent virus transmission.

“Who knows what the agency position will be by Friday,”tweeted Richard Corsi, an indoor air quality expert and dean of Portland State University’s college of engineering and computer science in Oregon. “To wear blinders to evidence is to bring a country to its knees.”

In a Washington Post op-ed published on Tuesday, Allen and Linsey C. Marr, a professor of civil and environmental engineering at Virginia Tech with expertise in airborne virus transmission, broke down the evidence supporting the conclusion that the virus is airborne ― and thus capable of person-to-person transmission through tiny respiratory droplets called aerosols.

“The science here is fairly straightforward. When you talk or sing — or even just breathe — you emit a range of particles of different sizes. Yes, there might be one or two particles that are large enough to see and that fall to the ground within six feet, but there are also thousands of particles that are smaller than five microns (or five millionths of a meter),” Allen and Marr wrote.

Nurses in Los Angeles participate in a national protest for personal protective equipment (PPE) and safer working practices i



Nurses in Los Angeles participate in a national protest for personal protective equipment (PPE) and safer working practices in August as the global outbreak of COVID-19 continues.

The tiny droplets can remain suspended in the air for longer periods of time, as well as travel farther, than larger droplets. In some cases, they’re able to travel well over 6 feet, which is the current physical distance recommended by the CDC.

“Our whole field has been shouting from the rooftops that airborne transmission was happening and that ventilation and filtration were crucial to limiting the spread of the disease,” Allen and Marr wrote.

The two professors citedone recent study, published in the International Journal of Infectious Diseases, that found viable samples of the coronavirus in air samples collected up to 16 feet away from patients hospitalized with COVID-19. No health procedures that would generate aerosols had taken place in the room, leading to the determination that the patients were generating the aerosols themselves by coughing, sneezing and even talking.

“For aerosol-based transmission, measures such as physical distancing by 6 feet would not be helpful in an indoor setting, provide a false sense of security and lead to exposures and outbreaks,” the study states.

Evidence has shown that the coronavirus, pictured here under a microscope, can spread in the air through tiny respiratory dro



Evidence has shown that the coronavirus, pictured here under a microscope, can spread in the air through tiny respiratory droplets called aerosols, scientists say. These can be released when someone coughs, sneezes, sings or talks.

Though the CDC and theWorld Health Organization have stated that airborne transmission of the virus has not been proven, Dr. Anthony Fauci, the top infectious disease expert in the U.S., last month said that the coronavirus “is much more aerosols than we thought,” citing evidence presented to him by aerosol and particle physicists. What remains unknown, he said at a panel Tuesday onCitizen by CNN,is the extent to which the aerosol component is contributing to the virus’s transmission.

“Rather than bending ourselves out of shape trying to figure out what percentage it is or is not or how well it’s proven, make an assumption that some component of it is aerosol and act accordingly, which means do what we’ve been telling you to do all along. It doesn’t change what we’re doing,” Fauci said.

Measures of protection recommended by Fauci include mask-wearing, social distancing and ensuring that indoor public spaces have open windows and are well-ventilated.

Many scientists reacting to Fauci’s comments on Twitter agreed.

“While it would be helpful to have CDC’s guidance on aerosols,”Marr tweeted,“it doesn’t change the fact that transmission by aerosols is happening and that we know how to address it.”

Calling all HuffPost superfans!

Sign up for membership to become a founding member and help shape HuffPost’s next chapter

Read More

18 COMMENTS

  1. My brother suggested I might like this web site. He was entirely right. This post actually made my day. You cann at imagine just how much time I had spent for this info! Thanks!

  2. Normally I don at read article on blogs, but I wish to say that this write-up very compelled me to try and do so! Your writing style has been amazed me. Thank you, quite great post.

  3. Modular Kitchens have changed the idea of kitchen in today as world as it has provided household women with a comfortable yet a classy area through which they could spend their quality time and space.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisment -

Most Popular

Ryder Cup 2010

McDowell knew the Twenty Ten course like the back of his hand. He’d won the Wales Open on the course that year and during a period when he lived in Cardiff he used the venue as his practice area.As the match descended into the home stretch McDowell sunk a 15-foot birdie to go 2-up on…

GB’s Evans calls opponents ’embarrassing’

Evans was knocked out in the singles in the first round by Kei Nishikori of JapanBritain's Dan Evans said his doubles opponents were "embarrassing" after becoming involved in an on-court row at the French Open.The British singles number one and Polish partner Hubert Hurkacz beat Dutchman Matwe Middelkoop and Brazilian Marcel Demoliner in the first…

US team walks off after ‘homophobic slur’

Collin Martin (pictured playing for former club Minnesota United) came out as gay in 2018Landon Donovan said his San Diego Loyal "would not stand" for bigotry having left the pitch in protest after an alleged homophobic comment was aimed at openly gay midfielder Collin Martin.An opposition player from Phoenix Rising was accused of making the…

As colleges reopened, many more young people got covid-19, CDC reports – msnNOW

Covid-19 cases surged nationally among 18- to 22-year-olds between Aug. 2 and Sept. 5, according to a report released Tuesday by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, which urged young adults as well as colleges and universities to take precautions to prevent the spread of the virus.Weekly cases among the age group jumped 55…